As you might’ve seen in my “gifts” post, I was blessed with the opportunity (and wonderful boyfriend) to pick out a few things from Sephora for my birthday. I chose 3 brown-ish lipsticks to try out as I’ve seen the shade a lot, really liked how it looked, but never had anything myself. Now that I’ve had the chance to try out each of these, I figured I’d share my experiences with you all for my first ever lipstick reviews:
^ Clinique- chubby stick in “graped-up”
I’ve had lots of experience with these before, and I can still say that I love this product! Any shade is perfect solely because it wears so well…
Transfer proof: no
Since it’s more of a balm there’s definitely going to be somewhat of a gloss showing up on your man’s cheek or your table napkin
Food proof 5/10
The texture/color is partially faded after eating, but you can still tell lipstick had been applied before
Kiss proof 5/10
Again, the texture/color ends up faded a bit
Application 9/10
Always smooth, and you don’t even need a mirror because it’s more of a balm
Texture 10/10
I will preach this forever! It’s the best feeling lipstick (if you can call it that) I’ve ever put on
Color 7/10
Some of the more “intense” shades of chubby sticks can glide on over your everyday lip balm and still show high pigmented color, but this one is a bit more subtle. Applied on clean/dry lips, the color is definitely more vibrant- I was hoping for a browner shade, but this is more on the red end of the spectrum
Longevity 9/10
Without eating or giving kisses, this product will last all day long
Packaging 10/10
Pretty and floral
Price 8/10
At $17.50 these are expensive for a lip balm, but cheap for a lip stick- so I’d say they’re a fair price!
Overall I was happy with it as I’d wear any color from this product line, but I do wish it was a bit more brown and a bit more pigmented. I’ll see what other colors are available next time I pop in (:
^ Smashbox- be legendary lipstick in “cognac”
My first ever experience with this brand, but I’d heard good things- which is what led me to look for a shade from their collection at Sephora…
Transfer proof: no
Still showed up on Justin’s mouth when I gave him a smooch
Food proof: no
Pretty much all gone after a meal
Kiss proof 5/10
Some color was left, but the shine was gone
Application 7.5/10
This one also needs to be applied before an everyday lip balm as the product won’t really stay on if there’s anything underneath
Texture 8.5/10
What I would consider “normal” lipstick consistency. This product has a lovely shine and non-drying feel
Color 7/10
I was expecting this to be more brown based on the name which describes an almost Carmel color, but again it’s really a red lipstick
Longevity 8/10
This doesn’t fade too much
Packaging 10/10
I adore the “box” case of this to go along with the brand name. Clever
Price 6/10
I wouldn’t have bought this on my own, because it’s over $20 (only by a buck). As a birthday gift though? I was excited to try it!
Overall thoughts on this one were great. I’ll obviously wear it again, but I wish it showed up more brown- I don’t think red is the best color on me as far as lipsticks go…
^ Make Up For Ever- artist rouge mat “M103”
I cannot express how much I fell in love with this lipstick! Just look how perfect that color is…
Transfer proof: no
Even though it’s considered “matte” the color still moves onto skin slightly
Food proof: no
This one was all but gone after I finished my tacos, but I was happy to re-apply
Kiss proof: yes
It stays on my lips after, but also on his…
Application 6/10
This lipstick slapped me in the face with the realization: in need of a lip-liner! My lips aren’t too well defined, so I’m sure it would’ve been MUCH easier to apply this if I had a matching liner on first
Texture 7/10
Of course this formula is semi-drying due to its matte consistency, but it doesn’t make my lips looked cracked or feel disgusting like some other ones I’ve tried. This applies perfectly over an everyday balm to lock in more moisture first
Color 10/10
Obviously. THIS is the brown I was looking for all along! It’s still not completely brown, but I didn’t want to get something that made me look chocolate-stained
Longevity 9/10
I didn’t see any fading in this one
Packaging 10/10
I love the “shotgun shell” look of the case and feel of the quality materials used
Price 10/10
The only reason I can give such a good score for this category is because it was on sale: $12 instead of the original $22
Overall, this was the winner of the three. I’ve already worn it on more than one occasion, and I see myself wearing it all fall long! I’d venture to say it’s a lipstick for every season as I’ve found my favorite (:
Which one did you like most? Have you tried any of these brands? What’s your go-to autumn lipstick? How did I do on my first reviews? (: let me know your thoughts in the comments!
I like MUFE’s the best on you 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks a lot 🤗
LikeLiked by 1 person
I definitely thought the last one looked best on you! And based on your reviews, if I were to try one I’d want to try that lol. I don’t wear a lot of makeup, so I don’t have that much experience trying so many lipsticks. I have been wanting to get a nice brown shade though!
Lovely review, though ☺️
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you for this sweet comment, so genuine! I’d recommend the Clinique one to you though (: the best starter “lipstick” cause it’s really more of a tinted balm. It feels incredible haha
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re very welcome ☺️ and I’ll have to give it a try. Thanks for the recommendation haha
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve never tried a brown lipstick but they look really good on you! Its got me curious. But also, I loved your reviews! They’re very practical, especially since you rate how well they stay after food or giving smooches 😂
LikeLiked by 2 people
Haha yes, gotta test them through everything! Thank you (: they’re all reddish browns as I’m just dipping my toe into the brown lipstick culture. I appreciate your comment xoxo
LikeLiked by 1 person
My boyfriends name is Justin too! Haha, I like the Makeup Forever one a lot! It looks great on you!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Neat haha twinning! Thanks so much (:
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha! Of course! ❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
Love this! Food proof 😂👌🏼 most important part
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks! I haven’t found one that completely lasts through a chow down (:
LikeLiked by 1 person
Instantly when i saw M103 on you, i was like YAAAASSSS and then you said you love it too. MMM. 😚
LikeLiked by 2 people
YAS 💁🏻 thank you very much!
LikeLiked by 1 person
All shades look so good on you!! Specially M103!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks a bunch! That one is my fave (:
LikeLike
I actually like the second one on you, even if you don’t like it that much. Third one is definitely the best one. I love the shade and it looks lovely on your lips xx ❤
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, Chey! The Smashbox one is quite good, so maybe I’ll look for a browner shade in the same style (: I appreciate you commenting xoxo
LikeLike
I absolutely love the Makeup Forever lipstick, the shade is so so gorgeous! xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much, it’s just the “brown” I was searching out (:
LikeLike
I think that last one was the best one! It looks amazing on you and I love how thoroughly you tested it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wanted to do a good job on my first reviews (: thanks so much for reading and your nice comment!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great review of all the lipsticks, the makeup forever one was my favorite! It also looked so good on you.😀💖
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks a bunch! That means a lot to me (:
LikeLike
Great post! These lipsticks all look amazing! I have a clinique stick highlighter and I love it
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks a ton! I’m sure it’s fabulous (: such a quality brand haha
LikeLiked by 1 person